What middle class teachers need to know about their working class pupils in poverty
Sometimes teaching feels like the great Victorian improvement project or missionary work. A bunch of well intentioned middle class people out to improve the poor or tame and civilise the savages. What do teachers actually know about how poverty affects the children they teach?
I’ve been educated and worked in middle class mostly white environments my whole life but I come from a Black working class one and some discussions that I have heard and been part of in my position as a teacher and leader in schools have left me very uncomfortable. There is often an assumption that we need to save people from themselves (both the children and their parents). Working class people are infantilised and automatically assumed inferior. Often in a well-meaning way but that’s definitely the subtext. That’s before we even get into the classist nature of many schools themselves. Look around your canteen, at your teaching assistants, your cleaners and most of your support staff then compare their backgrounds to the teaching staff before you start to disagree with me. The unspoken rule in education is that (white) middle class culture is the only meaningful culture and that we must all aspire to it. I’m pretty sure that at different points of my life I may have even perpetuated this.
I read some research recently that got me thinking about class and the assumptions that are made. How poverty affects people’s decision making processes by the Joseph Roundtree Foundation. I mentioned earlier that the assumption is that working class people need to be saved from themselves. This research explores how poverty affects decision making, choices and beliefs. It is vital that middle class professionals who work with children and young people from poor backgrounds understand how poverty affects how people think and behave. This may help us to have some empathy for the young people we work with and their families rather than judgment.
I present some of the findings that immediately caught my eye below
Poverty makes people concentrate on the present moment
Young people are notoriously poor at thinking about the future. Poor young people, even less so. I don’t know how things are now but back when I was a teenager in the 1990s some people had an electricity key. You topped it up at a shop and then used it at home and your electricity would last a certain amount of time. When the time or credit ran out so did your electricity. Image watching TV and it just stopping part way through a programme or trying to do your homework and the lights going out. That’s pretty stressful. Kayley may well decide to work for 25 hrs a week at below minimum wage if it means she could help her parents keep the lights on even though it’s not in the best interests of her GCSE or A-level course.
Community is more important to poor kids
“People lower in socio-economic status put lesser weight on personal aspirations and achievement in favour of helping others and conforming to community traditions.” We live in an individualistic society, especially the higher up the wealth ladder you are. It may be important as a middle class teacher to frame education in terms of how it will help poorer young people impact their community rather than how it will benefit them individually. I know that when I originally wanted to read medicine, I was interested in psychiatry because of the high rates of black people diagnosed with mental illness compared to relatively few Black psychiatrists for example.
It’s harder to trust people when you are poor, especially outsiders
The study found that growing up in poverty was linked to lower trust in others, possible because of feeling like an outsider in society and feeling a lack of control over what happens to you. This could explain the surly nature of some of the young people we teach from more deprived backgrounds. For many of my 14 years teaching I have taught an ‘intervention’ class of some type. Without fail the majority of these young people are often in receipt of pupil premium and do not make my job easy at all in the first few weeks. With time, structure, clear expectations, fairness and stubborn doggedness on my part as well as some decent maths and a healthy banter the situation always changes. Relationships are built and real learning eventually takes place but teachers have to remember to earn these young people’s trust rather than automatically expecting it because the world has not shown itself to be trust worthy to them.
Poor kids feel that what they do doesn’t matter
“People low in socio-economic status often see themselves as less able to learn new skills and succeed at tasks. They are also less likely to perceive that their actions will affect how their lives turn out.” If middle class teachers want to enact social change, we need to give poor kids the chance of success. Small wins. Step by step, related to their work, every single lesson. My surly intervention kids? It wasn’t listening to music or a £5 bribe that really worked (yes the £5 was every week of my own money back as an early teacher- I was desperate and out of ideas), it was seeing that they could actually do some maths, hard maths that they hadn’t been able to before and that they could then teach others. That’s what won them over- confidence in their own ability and not being patronized that 1+1 was good when they knew that all the other kids were doing quadratic equations.
If you were suddenly poor you’d be more likely to make ‘bad’ decisions too
The report presented evidence from other studies that found ”temporarily experiencing low subjective socio-economic status lowers people’s thinking performance and subsequent decision-making.” This suggests that poor decision making is not necessarily genetic although it may feel like that in schools when we are dealing with families who exhibit dysfunction across many siblings and generations. Instead the state of living in poverty and the associated stresses are having an effect and if, for some reason, we were temporarily in poverty- due to redundancy or relationship breakdown and an inability to cover our living costs, for example- then our decision making would be negatively affected too.
Final thoughts for teachers
If you teach in a school were many of your pupils are living in or near poverty, be aware that these conditions will affect their and their family’s ability to makes decisions that benefit them long term. This is not because these young people and their families are stupid or less intelligent than wealthier peers but rather because living in poverty is stressful and makes people concentrate on immediate ways to improve their situation or relive their suffering rather than long term solutions that may take them out of the situation altogether.
Enjoyed reading this blog post? Subscribe for future ones you’ll also get a free copy of my ‘9 Lessons for unexpected leaders’ pdf.
After initial publication here this blog post was later featured on TES.com as “What teachers should know about pupils in poverty” 15th May 2018
Susi Bates14th May 2018 at 7:06 am
Interesting and relevant points.
Lucyinldn14th May 2018 at 8:39 am
So much of this echoes my own experience in teaching. It baffles me as to why there is no clear progression path to move from TA to teacher, as this would enable many of those who have a wealth of local knowledge and experience to better serve the children they work with.
Iesha Small14th May 2018 at 9:20 pm
Interesting point, Lucy. I know a few TAs who have become teachers. School based routes into teaching are the best way for this, the old GTP used to be the main way.
Iesha Small29th May 2018 at 1:49 pm
Interesting point, I think school based training routes (esp paid ones) tend to be best suited to TAs. Local knowledge is very important, of course teachers who were bought up in the area and return to teach are also useful here.
Joan Stark14th May 2018 at 9:06 am
Thank you for bringing together so clearly the things I have observed and worked with over many years of working in a disadvantaged area
Susie14th May 2018 at 9:27 pm
Phew . What a relief to read this . It’s a common truth that never gets heard. Thank you for taking the time and for being there and getting it .
Iesha Small29th May 2018 at 1:46 pm
The time was worth it.
Lauren15th May 2018 at 7:51 am
This is a clear and informative post, thank you. I grew up working class in near poverty at times with a mother struggling with mental health problems and a step father in prison (my father had died when I was young). I am now a teacher in a very deprived area of London and I am so proud of the resilience, empathy and hard work of the children I work with.
Iesha Small29th May 2018 at 1:45 pm
Glad it resonates with you Lauren. There has been a huge response to this post- it’s clearly hit a nerve.
Thinking about poverty and thinking. - ollie lovell24th May 2018 at 1:00 pm
[…] some of the key findings and weaving in personal reflections along the way. Her piece is entitled What middle class teachers need to know about their working class pupils in poverty. If you’re a teacher who works with disadvantaged students, I suggest you check it out. […]
Iesha Small29th May 2018 at 1:44 pm
Thanks for reading Ollie.